COGSyour voice in the system
         
 

 

Minutes
General Assembly of the Council of Graduate Students
University of Minnesota
April, 2004

Minutes by Sean McNee, Vice President for Communications
Approved by the COGS Executive Committee

Quorum was met.

5pm -- food served

5:15pm -- Introductory comments:Chris Pappas, President

Welcome to the April General Assembly Meeting. This month we are having elections, so thanks for coming and thanks for running! Before we elect new officers, I have few announcements to make.

First, I would like to remind everyone about the COGS Leadership Awards and the COGS Travel and Educational Awards. We give out leadership awards to graduate students who demonstrate leadership and service on behalf of their fellow graduate students, the University, and broader communities. Applications for the Leadership award are due April 23rd. Starting this year, COGS also will be giving out Travel and Educational Grant Awards. These awards are for graduate students to travel to conferences or other educational programs not offered at the University of Minnesota. The application deadline for the Travel and Eduational Grant Awards was today, April 1st. Information about both of these awards, including application instructions, is available from the COGS website.

Second, I would like to announce that April 11th to the 17th is Graduate and Professional Student Appreciation Week. Abu Jalal, the Vice President for Finance for GAPSA, is here to mention a little more about this.

Comments from Abu Jalal:

Every year GAPSA sponsors Graduate and Professional Student Appreciation Week. This year, we are getting Governor Palenty to sign a proclamation about Appreciation Week. There will be many events for graduate and professional students this week including an ice cream extravaganza, free massages, and family bowling night. To go along with Appreciation Week, there are also Discount Cards available to all graduate and professional students which provides discounts to several companies around campus. The cards are good for the entire month of April. More information about Graduate and Professional Student Appreciation Week is available from the GAPSA website.

COGS note: COGS has a large stack of the Discount cards. If any rep would like a stack to take back to their department, please contact COGS and we can either campus mail them to you or you can pick them up from our office.

Also speaking of GAPSA, they are having their elections at their next assembly meeting on April 27th. GAPSA is, of course, the umbrella parent organization of COGS. If anyone is interested in running for a GAPSA position, please email me for more information and visit the GAPSA website for job descriptions.

COGS note: The GAPSA website should be updated to contain the new job descriptions by April 7th.

Finally, Beautiful U day is coming up on April 22nd. There are many events occurring, including the painting of the Washington Avenue Bridge. I encourage everyone to participate.

One more thing, thanks to everyone who has turned on your stadium surveys. If you haven’t done so yet, please turn in your surveys as soon as possible. The stadium committees are continuing to meet, and it is important to get graduate student opinion about the stadium to everyone on the committee.

COGS note: If you have stadium surveys you want to send it, please email our representative to the stadium committee, Keith Cunnien, directly with your results and comments. For those of you who may have lost your copy of the survey, electronic versions of the stadium survey are also available.

5:20pm -- AAUP: Jeremy Nienow,TC AAUP GSC Chair

COGS would like to thank Jeremy Nienow from the Twin Cities AAUP Graduate Student Caucus to talk to the GA about the AAUP.

Comments from Jeremy Nienow:

The Twin Cities AAUP Graduate Student Caucus (GSC) is a small organization that just started this year. We are interested in issues of academic freedom and intellectual property rights all graduate students and faculty. We want to bring these issues to the attention of graduate students here at the U of MN. AAUP is the American Association of University Professors. It was established in 1915 and has 40,000 professors as members. The organization deals mostly with professor and academic rights, but graduate students can work with them too. For example, the AAUP works to get TAs rights at Universities similarly to those of professors.

The AAUP decided to form its first Graduate Student Caucus here at the University of Minnesota. I am here to ask all of you in COGS in you are interested in getting involved with the AAUP and the TC AAUP GSC. Our rights are getting eroded, and they could be getting worse. For example, there is a push to have more adjunct faculty and fewer tenure positions at many schools. If you are interested in these issues and want an inside scoop, want to meet more professors, what to know more about politics at MN or compare our politics to other schools, consider joining the AAUP. Also consider joining our Graduate Student Caucus. The Caucus is small now, but we are looking to grow.

The first meeting of the U of MN AAUP Graduate Student Caucus will be on April 22nd, in the HHH Center, Room 25 at 5:30pm. We will be having our elections for next year. There will be free food and drinks. Also please consider joining AAUP. It is only $10 a year for students. Membership gets you access to journals and to discounts. Please contact me if you have any questions or comments.

Questions from the GA:

Q. Doesn’t AAUP publish a book every year listing salaries of different faculty positions at universities across the country? Do you get a copy of that if you join?

A. Yes, AAUP does publish a report every year about salaries. As far as I know, if you are a student member, you get a copy of that report. I’m looking forward to getting my copy.

Q. Can international students be members of the AAUP?

A. Yes, they can, and I encourage everyone who is interested in AAUP to join.

Q. Is AAUP working on this problem of contingent faculty positions?

A. This is a big issue. AAUP thinks that the growth of contingent faculty positions is eroding and could eventually destroy the tenure process. The AAUP works with universities to get rules and processes in place to prevent the growth of these positions. We are lucky at the University of Minnesota because the University Senate has already said that there are limits as to the percentage of contingent positions allowed here. This is a good thing, as I want to be able to get my degree and be able to teach without having to be worried about being cycled through after a few years.

5:30pm -- Elections: Chris Pappas, President

Welcome to COGS elections!

We distributed two handouts at the meeting. One was a list of job descriptions; the same information can be found on the COGS website. The second was a document explaining the basics of Robert's Rules of Order for elections (elections are one of the few times when COGS is strict about using Robert's Rules to ensure fair process).

In summary, the floor must be opened for nominations for a position. Then, someone must be nominated and seconded for a position (they must accept the nomination, of course). After all interested parties have been nominated, the floor for nominations must be closed. If there are multiple people running for a position, all voting occurs by written ballet.

COGS Note: Elections were held one Executive Officer at a time, and then due to time contraints, elections were held as a group for the full slate of Senators and as a group for the full slate of P&R Council Chairs.

COGS is pleased to announce the results of our April elections. Thank you to everyone who ran!

COGS Executive Officers Elect for 2004-2005
President Britt Johnson
Executive Vice President Shana Watters
Vice President for Internal Relations Elizabeth Oliva
Vice President for Finance Andrew Warta
Vice President for External Relations Rafael Ortiz
Vice President for Communications Isaac Kamola

COGS Note: The COGS Parlimentarian position was not filled at this meeting. This position is a non-voting position on the Executive Committee appointed by the President. If anyone is interested in this position, please contact COGS for more information.

COGS Note: The Vice President for Finance position is usually elected in the fall. Andrew Warta has been elected to finish out the rest of Michael Olin's term. Regular elections for the VP for Finance position will still be held next fall.

COGS Student Senators Elect for 2004-2005
Jamie Larson
Kristen Houlton
Sean Sizler
Keith Cunnien
Chris Pappas
Alexsa Babic
San-San Luah
Senate Alternates Elect for 2004-2005
Laurie Stone
Samantha Ammons
Dan Drake

 

COGS P&R Council Chairs Elect for 2004-2005
Education and Psychology Sara Kempner
Biological Sciences [open]
Languages, Literature and Arts Charles Adams
Social Sciences Keith Cunnien
Engineering, Physical, and Mathematical Sciences Eric Smith
Health Sciences Megan Warren

COGS Note: COGS did not elect a chair to the Biological Sciences P&R Council. We will be holding elections for this position again at the May GA meeting.

Congratulations to all who where elected! This is very exciting for COGS to have all of these positions filled. Those who are newly elected may have obligations starting in the next month. COGS will be in contact with you to let you know what will happen.

6:05pm -- Resolution: Chris Pappas, President

There was only one resolution for consideration at this GA meeting. This was the resolution that first appeared at the March GA meeting, but was eventually tabled due to lack of time.

Comments from the resolution author, Isaac Kamola:

This is the same resolution that appears at last month’s GA. In short, it states that the U needs to readjust its priorities as tuition continues to go through the roof. It is ridiculous that the University is getting people to fund a new stadium but cannot find money to pay its workers and graduate students. The University of Minnesota is a land grant institution and it needs to put education first financially. Tuition is too high. This resolution is a reminder to the University administration that teaching should come first and that a university education should be accessible and affordable to everyone in the state of Minnesota.

COGS Note: There was a handout given to all present at the GA about the University’s capital bonding request for this year. The University asks for funding from the state in biannual cycles where all funding requests in even-numbered years are capital requests for building improvements, etc. and all funding requests in odd-numbered are for the University general fund to pay for teaching, research, etc. This exact handout is currently unavailable for download, but similar information is available from the University's website about the bonding request.

Comments from the GA:

COGS Note: They were many comments from the GA about this resolution. It was difficult to record all stated comments in detail, especially those that proposed friendly amendments to the resolution. COGS apologizes for not getting all comments recorded about this resolution, but hopes that comments recorded accurately reflect the nature of the discussion about the resolution. Only comments from the resolution’s author and from COGS President Pappas are marked as such. The rest are from members of the GA, including other executive officers.

The wording of this resolution seems vague. What do we hope to accomplish and change with a resolution of this nature? We should use the power of our resolutions to act on specific problems for graduate students. I am worried that this is not specific enough to mean anything.

I am worried about the particular phasing of “vanity projects.” What are vanity project exactly? And could that phrasing be changed? The phrasing my not invoke the kind of response from the administration that we are looking for.

Isaac: By ‘vanity projects’ I was referring to the fact that University spends a lot of money on nice buildings, flowerbeds, and other projects not central to teaching. I am completely open to any other way to rephrase these ideas.

In a note about some projects at the University, the Athletics program was supposed to self-sustaining, but it is in fact a deficit producing program and the funding for it is going up. This should be considered as a part of the resolution.

COGS Note: In other Big 10 schools such as Michigan, Iowa, and Ohio State, the school generates enough revenue from sporting events such that athletics are revenue generating for the school. In some extreme cases, such as Michigan, the extra revenue from men’s football alone is enough to fully fund all other men’s and women’s athletics. The U of MN is in a minority of Division I schools that have to subsidize their athletics program.

If we pass this resolution, the University administration is going to come back and say that building an on-campus stadium is going to make Athletics self-sustaining and hopefully revenue generating. We need to be prepared with how we are going to react to these comments.

The phrasing in the beginning of the resolution seems out of place. The resolution starts off by talking the hardships of University employees. Shouldn’t the resolution focus more on the hardships of graduate students?

There are differences and restrictions in how the University receives funding from the state and from donations by alumni. Some pools of money cannot be allocated to teaching and research no matter how hard we try. By sending in this resolution we showing some ignorance as to how the University handles its budget. We need more specific information about money allocation before we can have an effective resolution on this issue.

There are differences in funding and I don’t think this resolution shows any real ignorance in money allocations. If we wait and get more specific about funding, then they can simply respond to the specified concern and perhaps weasel out of talking about the larger picture for funding priorities. The resolution needs to be general about funding.

I would be worried if it betrayed ignorance, but I don’t think that it does. Brunnicks was quoted earlier saying that he knew that requests for money from the legislature for helping students wouldn’t pass, so he didn’t ask for them. Is he trying to be savvy? Why didn’t he ask for money? We need this resolution.

President Chris Pappas: I usually don’t say too much about resolutions, but instead only take them to be mandates from the GA and do what I can from that point forward. Having said that, I have a few comments. The resolution is better as an affirmation about what the University is doing. President Bruinnicks was on NPR this morning, and after talking about basketball and hockey and during a discussion of the stadium, he said over and over again that he will not sacrifice the academic mission of the University for a new stadium. A college president will always say this, but I think it would be better to take him at face value on this and hold him to it. We just want to tell him in this resolution that we are going to hold him to these statements and perhaps work with him to make it so.

The resolution fits in well with what we have been trying to do all year. But perhaps the resolution should focus on saying that we are trying to fill our needs, and the administration needs to help. It should say that we are working hard and we hear from the administration that they have our needs at heart. We just want the administration to hold up their end of the bargain.

Isaac: How is the current money the University collected being allocated? Just take a look at Coffman. It was way over budget and we are paying $50 a semester for it. The stadium is going to be the same way. And this resolution says the administration needs to be accountable for this, and get back to focusing on spending money for teaching.

There are differences in some capital requests. Carlson School of Management needs a new building for undergraduate education. They can only accept 10% of the students that apply there. Money for these projects do need to be accepted and are not vanity. I am against building stadiums.

The resolution should talk about research too. While the resolution mentions teaching and education quite often, if fails to mention that we also perform research here at the University as well.

The resolution with accepted friendly amendments was read aloud to the GA. It was then called to a vote.

The resolution as read aloud passed with 27 in favor, 7 against, and 3 abstaining.

COGS Note: For clarity, comments and discussion concerning the specific language changes to both the resolution and to the proposed friendly amendments have been edited out of the GA minutes. Copies of the resolution as submitted by Isaac and as finally adopted by the GA are both available for download.

6:35 -- Committee Reports

OneStop Student Advisory Committee – Sean McNee

There are three things of interest:

  • OneStop is working on a website redesign that should be completed for fall semester. They promise a more usable and consistent website.
  • OneStop is working on the myU portal and is hoping that student will start using it. In particular, they have created a version of the portal for incoming first year students, called the “Class of 2008 portal”.
  • OneStop is working on an online waitlist for all classes. Thus, when registering for classes, if a class is full, a student would be offered chance to be immediately added to the waitlist. Adding the class will still require a ‘magic number’. Waitlist information is available to the professor and the department offering the class and they can decide their own policies for issuing magic numbers to waitlisted students.

Language, Literature & Arts P&R Council Report -- Charles Adams

There are two items to mention: first are changes from SEVIS that all P&R councils will be hearing about. Second concerns PPF courses and the LLA departments.

SEVIS

This information is going to be sent out to all departments at their P&R meetings. There are serious changes occurring for international graduate students as a reflection of SEVIS. In particular, international students need to know the following:

  1. If an international student interrupts their studies and leaves the USA for any reason, they need to report their leave BEFORE the go.
  2. International students are limited in the number of distance learning courses they can be registered for per semester.
  3. International students must maintain full time graduate student status and are only allowed one exception. There used to be multiple exceptions allowed.
  4. If an international student needs to apply for a new visa and is going to be out of the country, they need to submit their visa application BEFORE they leave.

This information was given to the P&R council by ISSS.

PFF and LLA

After receiving many complaints where graduate students in LLA departments could not take PFF courses, the P&R Council and the Graduate School are seriously reviewing the situation and hope to resolve it soon.

University Fee Update – Sean McNee

According to the Deans of the Graduate School, the University Fee is covered for all TAs and RAs as a part of the benefits package. For most job classifications, this coverage is pre-programmed in PeopleSoft and cannot be changed by the department even if they wanted to. Please check your billing statements carefully comparing the total amount charged for tuition and the University Fee and compare it to the total amount credited for your benefits.

Some RAs and Fellowships are paid directly by government funding. By Federal Law, this funding cannot pay student fees, and technically the University Fee is a student fee. Departments with these kinds of RAs and Fellowships are still supposed to proactively pay the University Fee for students on these assistantships.

If you are on an assistantship of any kind and you are paying the University Fee, please contact COGS immediately so we can tell the Deans what is happening. The Graduate School is very interested in resolving this situation as soon as possible.

University Senate Meeting – Jamie Larson

COGS note: This senate information was submitted by Jamie Larson for inclusion into these GA minutes. Thanks, Jamie!

President Bruininks started the meeting off with giving an overview of some important issues to students. He mentioned the capitol bonding request, and asked for student support in getting full funding. Due to the financial cuts, he thought it was important to spread the cuts across the board. Therefore, tuition will rise again in the coming year and 500-600 employees have been cut and those not cut are asked to pay more of their healthcare. There has been an increase of three million dollars in scholarships and financial aid to those in need to help compensate for the increase in tuition. The President briefly mentioned the stadium, saying that no matter what, something has to be done because the lease on the metrodome is up in 2011. There were some questions answered from student feedback via email. The first dealt with reciprocity of Wisconsin students and he wanted them to have to pay the same amount Minnesota students pay. The second dealt with the increase enrollment at Duluth and he said they are trying to manage the growth. The third was about the bus strike and he expressed his concern and hopes that it will soon end.

Also at the meeting, a brief discussion about student housing was brought up. A committee has formed and one of the things they are looking into is increasing housing for graduate and married student housing. We also discussed the policy on whether senators should be required to serve on committees. Nothing was decided at the meeting. The senate reorganization was briefly discussed, and should come up for a vote at the April University Senate meeting.

The University Senate meeting was cancelled (for the second time this academic year!) due to “lack of agenda items”. The next student and university senate meeting will be held on April 29th.

Duluth Road Trip – Chris Pappas

COGS is planning to drive up to Duluth on Friday April 23rd. We are hoping to talk with graduate students up there about their issues and concerns. We want to ensure that Duluth graduate students have representation, and we are working both with the Graduate School, the Duluth administration, and Duluth graduate students to make sure this happens. If anyone from the GA wants to drive up to Duluth with us, please contact Chris Pappas for more information.

Stadium Committee Meeting -- Chris Pappas and Keith Cunnien

There was a meeting called with several administrators and members from COGS about the stadium last week. Apparently they heard about Isaac’s resolution and were worried that it was going to be directly about the stadium. They now are seriously listening to us about the stadium. We ended up having a good conversation with the administrators about many of the issues that we have concerns about, more than just the stadium. This includes feelings of dissatisfaction with the University. The full stadium committee meets again on Wednesday. If you have information or comments you want sent to the stadium committee, please contact our representative, Keith Cunnien, directly.

Comments from the GA:

I may not be fully satisfied with the University, but it took me so long to realize what was actually happening here that by the time I was unhappy I already had enough invested so that I don’t want to leave. I’m going to just grit my teeth and tough it out.

If you are a TA or an RA, leaving could be considered a breach of contract. There are some contractual obligations about being on an assistantship that has come up as a part of our ethics training.

COGS Note: As a reminder, if you still have stadium surveys that you have not sent into COGS, please send them directly to Keith.

SHAC -- Andrew Rivard

Boynton Health Services received a recommendation for full funding from the Fees Committee. This is very good for Boynton, and therefore also very good for anyone who uses Boynton's services.

GAPSA -- Chris Pappas

At the last GAPSA meeting, a constitutional amendment was passed stating that the full GAPSA assembly should vote on a call for removal of a member of the GAPSA executive committee from office. This is a change from the current constitution which states that only the GAPSA Executive Committee needs to meet and vote on such issues.

COGS Note: This GAPSA constitutional amendment was submitted to GAPSA by COGS President Chris Pappas on behalf of all of the COGS Executive Officers. This amendment was submitted in response to the attempted removal of current GAPSA President, Todd Powell, from office. The GAPSA Executive committee met and voted on the removal (keeping Todd in office) without informing the rest of GAPSA Assembly, as was allowed in the previous verison of the GAPSA Constitution. For more information, see coverage from the MN Daily: February 25th and March 31st.

COGS Note: The COGS Constitution and Bylaws state that a COGS elected officer can only be removed from office with a two-third majority vote from the COGS General Assembly.

Also, the Fees Committee recommended that GAPSA receive $450,000 in funding of the $480,000 that they asked for. We in COGS have been told that if GAPSA receives this recommended level of funding, then COGS will be fully funded for next year. That is very good news for us.

6:55pm -- Meeting adjourned.

COGS Note: COGS is very sorry that the meeting ran over the allotted time. Elections and the in-depth discussion of the resolution left little time for the committee reports. Thank you to everyone who stayed for the entire meeting.

COGS Note: The May GA meeting is the last GA for this academic year. We hope that everyone will attend. As an extra reason to come, COGS is finalizing the procurement of an alcohol permit from the University for the May GA.

 
 

This website has valid HTML 4.01 syntax.
This website has valid CSS syntax.

Council of Graduate Students | 405 Johnston Hall | 612.626.1612 | cogs@umn.edu